VS
VersusStack
Ecommerce ✓ Verified 2026-02-26

BigCommerce vs Shopify

Shopify is the market leader with the biggest ecosystem. BigCommerce has more built-in features and no transaction fees. One is easier; the other gives you more out of the box.

Last updated: 2026-02-26

⚡ Quick Verdict

Shopify dominates ecommerce for a reason: it's the easiest to start with and has the largest app/theme ecosystem. BigCommerce is the smarter choice for businesses that need advanced features out of the box — multi-channel selling, no transaction fees, unlimited staff accounts, and more product options without paying for apps. But Shopify's ecosystem advantage is massive.

BigCommerce is best for

Mid-market and B2B businesses that want built-in features (multi-channel, no transaction fees, unlimited variants). Stores that don't want to rely on paid apps for core functionality.

Shopify is best for

New and growing merchants who want the easiest setup, biggest theme marketplace, and largest app ecosystem. Brands that value design and simplicity.

BigCommerce dealbreaker

Smaller theme selection. Fewer apps. Revenue caps on plans that force upgrades. Less intuitive admin.

Shopify dealbreaker

Transaction fees unless you use Shopify Payments. Core features require paid apps. Costs add up with apps.

Choose BigCommerce if…

  • →You want no transaction fees on any payment gateway — BigCommerce doesn't charge them
  • →You need advanced features built-in: multi-channel, product variants, bulk pricing
  • →You're a B2B business needing customer groups, quote management, and purchase orders
  • →You want unlimited staff accounts on all plans
  • →You prefer not to rely on paid third-party apps for core ecommerce features

Choose Shopify if…

  • →You want the largest theme and app marketplace in ecommerce
  • →You're a new merchant who values the easiest possible setup
  • →You want Shopify Payments for integrated payments, POS, and Shop Pay
  • →You plan to sell on social media (Instagram, TikTok Shop) — Shopify's integrations are deeper
  • →You value a massive community of developers, designers, and experts
Try BigCommerce Free → Try Shopify Free →

Get the Free SaaS Stack Cheat Sheet

The top 3 tools in every category — updated monthly. One page, no fluff.

Don't pick BigCommerce if…

  • ✕You want the biggest selection of themes and apps — BigCommerce's marketplace is smaller
  • ✕You're a beginner who values simplicity above all — BigCommerce has a steeper learning curve
  • ✕Your revenue might trigger plan upgrades — BigCommerce has annual revenue caps per plan

Don't pick Shopify if…

  • ✕You don't want to use Shopify Payments — other gateways incur 0.5-2% transaction fees
  • ✕You don't want to pay for apps to get features BigCommerce includes free
  • ✕You need unlimited product variants — Shopify limits to 100 variants per product
  • ✕You're a B2B business — Shopify's B2B features require Plus ($2,000+/mo)

Feature Comparison

Pricing

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
Starting price$39/mo$39/mo
Transaction feesNone0.5-2% (or use Shopify Payments)

Products

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
Product variants600 (unlimited with workarounds)100 (requires apps for more)

Team

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
Staff accountsUnlimited on all plans2-15 depending on plan

Design

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
Theme selection~200 themes150+ free + thousands paid

Ecosystem

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
App marketplace1,500+ apps8,000+ apps
Community/resourcesModerateMassive

Experience

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
Ease of useGoodBest in class

Sales

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
Multi-channel sellingBuilt-inBuilt-in
Social commerceGoodBest in class (Instagram, TikTok Shop)

B2B

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
B2B featuresBuilt-in on all plansRequires Plus ($2,000+/mo)
Customer groupsBuilt-inRequires apps

Retail

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
POS systemAvailable (limited)Shopify POS (excellent)

Marketing

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
SEO featuresGood (customizable URLs)Good

Technical

FeatureBigCommerceShopify
Headless commerceStrong APIsHydrogen + Storefront API

Honest Tradeoffs

Every tool has tradeoffs. Here's what you're actually choosing between.

Transaction Fees

BigCommerce

No transaction fees on any payment gateway. Use Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.net — no surcharge.

Shopify

0.5-2% transaction fee if you don't use Shopify Payments. Shopify Payments has no fee but limits payment gateway choice.

If you process $500K+/year and don't want to be locked into Shopify Payments, BigCommerce saves thousands in fees.

Built-in Features

BigCommerce

Multi-channel selling, unlimited variants, customer groups, bulk pricing, faceted search — all built-in.

Shopify

Many features require paid apps: product reviews ($0-25/mo), advanced filtering ($10-50/mo), loyalty programs ($30-200/mo).

BigCommerce includes features that cost $50-200/month in Shopify apps. Calculate your total cost of ownership, not just the base plan.

App Ecosystem

BigCommerce

1,500+ apps. Covers the essentials but smaller selection.

Shopify

8,000+ apps. If you can imagine it, there's a Shopify app for it.

Shopify's app ecosystem is its superpower. BigCommerce has what you need, but Shopify has 5x the options. This matters most for niche requirements.

Ease of Use

BigCommerce

Capable but more complex. Admin interface has a learning curve.

Shopify

Best-in-class onboarding. Intuitive admin. Themes are drag-and-drop.

Shopify invested more in UX. A non-technical person can set up a Shopify store in an afternoon. BigCommerce takes longer to master.

Revenue Caps

BigCommerce

Standard: $50K/yr. Plus: $180K/yr. Pro: $400K/yr. Exceed the cap and you're forced to upgrade.

Shopify

No revenue caps on any plan.

BigCommerce's revenue caps are a real issue for growing stores. You can outgrow your plan fast.

B2B Features

BigCommerce

Built-in: customer groups, quote management, purchase orders, bulk pricing rules.

Shopify

B2B features require Shopify Plus ($2,000+/mo) or paid apps.

For B2B ecommerce, BigCommerce at $299/mo includes what Shopify charges $2,000+/mo for.

Pricing

BigCommerce

$39/moper month (Standard plan)
Try BigCommerce Free →

Shopify

$39/moper month (Basic plan)
Try Shopify Free →

Pros & Cons

BigCommerce

Pros

  • +No transaction fees on any payment gateway
  • +More built-in features than Shopify (variants, bulk pricing, customer groups)
  • +Strong B2B features without requiring the highest tier
  • +Unlimited staff accounts on all plans
  • +Multi-channel selling included (Amazon, eBay, social)
  • +Headless commerce ready with strong APIs

Cons

  • −Smaller theme marketplace (~200 themes)
  • −Smaller app ecosystem (1,500+ vs Shopify's 8,000+)
  • −Revenue caps force plan upgrades
  • −Admin interface is less intuitive than Shopify
  • −Smaller community and fewer development resources
  • −Checkout customization is limited compared to Shopify

Shopify

Pros

  • +Largest app and theme marketplace in ecommerce
  • +Best-in-class ease of use and onboarding
  • +Shopify Payments + Shop Pay for seamless checkout
  • +Powerful POS for retail stores
  • +Deep social commerce integrations (Instagram, TikTok Shop)
  • +Massive community of developers, designers, and agencies

Cons

  • −Transaction fees (0.5-2%) unless using Shopify Payments
  • −Core features often require paid apps ($50-200/mo in app costs)
  • −Limited product variants (100 per product)
  • −B2B features require Plus ($2,000+/mo)
  • −Shopify Payments not available in all countries
  • −Template language (Liquid) has a learning curve for developers

What the Data Says

Real numbers, real quotes, real outcomes — not marketing copy.

📊Data Point

Shopify powers 4.6M+ stores globally and processed $236B in GMV in 2024, making it the largest independent ecommerce platform.

Source: Shopify FY2024 Report

📊Data Point

BigCommerce serves 60,000+ merchants across 150+ countries, with average GMV growth of 25% year-over-year for Enterprise merchants.

Source: BigCommerce Annual Report, 2025

💬Quote

"We switched from Shopify to BigCommerce and eliminated $800/month in app fees. Everything we were paying for on Shopify was built into BigCommerce."

Source: D2C brand founder on eCommerceFuel

📊Data Point

Shopify's app marketplace has 8,000+ apps, compared to BigCommerce's 1,500+. More options but higher total cost of ownership.

Source: Platform marketplaces, 2025

Detailed Breakdown

The Transaction Fee Trap

BigCommerce wins

Shopify charges 0.5-2% transaction fees unless you use Shopify Payments. For a store doing $500K/year, that's $2,500-10,000 in fees. BigCommerce charges zero transaction fees on any payment gateway. If you prefer PayPal, Stripe, or a regional payment processor, BigCommerce saves real money. If you're happy with Shopify Payments, this doesn't matter.

Built-in vs App Store

BigCommerce wins

BigCommerce includes features that Shopify requires paid apps for: product reviews, advanced filtering, customer groups, bulk pricing, and more. A typical Shopify store spends $50-200/month on apps. BigCommerce's approach means lower total cost — but Shopify's app ecosystem means more choice and best-in-class solutions for each feature.

Ecosystem & Community

Shopify wins

Shopify has 4.6M+ stores, 8,000+ apps, thousands of themes, and the largest ecommerce developer community on earth. Need a custom feature? There's a Shopify expert. Need a niche integration? There's an app. BigCommerce's smaller ecosystem means fewer options and sometimes settling for "good enough."

The Ease of Use Gap

Shopify wins

Shopify is the easiest ecommerce platform to use. A non-technical person can launch a store in a day. BigCommerce is more capable out of the box but takes longer to set up and has a steeper learning curve. For first-time merchants, this difference is meaningful.

Switching Costs

Already using one? Here's what it takes to switch.

BigCommerce → Shopify

Moderate — a few days

Shopify → BigCommerce

Moderate — a few days

Both support CSV import/export for products, customers, and orders. Apps like Cart2Cart automate the migration. The main work is theme recreation and app replacement. Budget 2-4 weeks for a mid-sized store.

FAQ

Is BigCommerce cheaper than Shopify? ▾
Base prices are similar ($39/mo). But BigCommerce has no transaction fees and more built-in features, so total cost of ownership is often lower. Calculate your app costs on Shopify before comparing.
Why do most people choose Shopify over BigCommerce? ▾
Ease of use and ecosystem. Shopify is easier to start with, has more themes and apps, and has a bigger community. For most small merchants, these advantages outweigh BigCommerce's feature advantages.
Can I migrate from Shopify to BigCommerce? ▾
Yes. BigCommerce has a Shopify migration app. Products, customers, and orders transfer. Themes need to be recreated. Budget 2-4 weeks.
Which is better for B2B? ▾
BigCommerce, by a wide margin. Customer groups, quote management, purchase orders, and bulk pricing are built in. Shopify requires Plus ($2,000+/mo) for comparable B2B features.
What about BigCommerce's revenue caps? ▾
Standard caps at $50K/yr, Plus at $180K/yr, Pro at $400K/yr. Exceeding the cap forces a plan upgrade. This is the biggest BigCommerce complaint. Shopify has no revenue caps.
Which is better for dropshipping? ▾
Shopify. More dropshipping apps (Oberlo, DSers, Spocket), more suppliers, and a larger community of dropshippers sharing knowledge.

Neither feels right?

Consider WooCommerce — If you want full control with open-source flexibility. WooCommerce on WordPress is free (hosting extra) and infinitely customizable, but requires more technical skill.

Related Comparisons

E-Commerce

Shopify vs BigCommerce

Shopify wins overall — the ecosystem, app marketplace, theme selection, and brand recognition make it the safest choice.…

Ecommerce

Shopify vs Etsy

Start on Etsy if you need fast demand validation, but build on Shopify if you want a durable brand and direct ownership …

Ecommerce

Shopify vs Wix

Shopify wins for anyone serious about ecommerce. It's purpose-built for selling — better checkout, better inventory mana…

Ecommerce

Shopify vs WooCommerce

Shopify wins for most ecommerce businesses. It's faster to launch, easier to maintain, and the total cost of ownership i…

Website Builders

Squarespace vs Shopify

Use Shopify if commerce is your business model, but use Squarespace if brand presentation and content matter more than a…

Browse all Ecommerce comparisons →

Ready to choose?

Both tools offer free plans. Try them and see which fits.

Try BigCommerce Free → Try Shopify Free →